UFO UpDates
A mailing list for the study of UFO-related phenomena
'Its All Here In Black & White'
Location: UFOUpDatesList.Com > 1999 > Oct > Oct 17

Re: Alien Ineptitude

From: Joseph Polanik <jpolanik@mindspring.com>
Date: Sat, 16 Oct 1999 20:53:55 GMT
Fwd Date: Sun, 17 Oct 1999 18:08:06 -0400
Subject: Re: Alien Ineptitude

 >Date: Tue, 12 Oct 1999 16:11:21 +0200
 >To: UFO UpDates - Toronto <updates@globalserve.net>
 >From: Christophe Meessen <meessen@cppm.in2p3.fr>
 >Subject: Re: Alien Ineptitude

 >When trying to understand why ET are mutilating animals, we must
 >be careful to avoid asumptions.

How reasonable is it to theorize, from what little evidence we
have, that ETs are the ones responsible for animal mutilations?

 >In your case you assume that they are interested in getting huge
 >quantities of the substance itself.

Someone questioning the ETMT (ET as Mutilator Theory) might ask
'Why would ETs want to mutilate cattle?'.

If the reply is that the mutilators need some substance found in
the rectums of Earth cattle, we should be able to ask 'How
reasonable is it to assume that ETs having the technology to
travel to Earth would be *required* to travel to Earth again and
again to collect the precious BRS [Bovine Rectum Substance]
because they are ...

1. Unable to find the BRS anywhere closer to home;

2. Unable to synthesize the substance at home;

3. Unable to steal a bull and a few cows to establish their own

4. Unable to genetically engineer any of their own bacteria,
    plants or animals to produce the precious BRS.

5. Etc.

In another strand of this thread Lesley Cluff answers question 2
as follows:

 >Synthesizing just isn't a miracle answer - yet.  So if we can't
 >do it here with a constant and consistent success rate, why do
 >we think everyone else in the universe can?  We haven't unlocked
 >all the mysteries of our own human biology much less that of our
 >environment, so why should we believe every other 'alien' race

How convenient.

We explain ETs presence on Earth by assuming they have
technology far superior to our own.

We explain ETs behavior while on Earth by assuming that they
don't have technology much advanced over our own.

Trying to have it both ways is a good example of ad hoc reasoning.

 >If we suppose they know how to synthetize any substance in big
 >quantities, the most rational explanation is that they are
 >simply probing and measuring.

It _is_ far more reasonable to suppose that ETs are probing and
measuring than it is to suppose that they need the precious BRS
for their own use.

However, we should be able to question this theory (if we can
assume that this supposition is a full grown theory) by asking
'Why would they have to kill the cattle?'.

If ET was genuinely concerned about secrecy, why would they
leave all those dead cows lying around? Why not use the same
sample extraction techniques on the cattle as they do on the

When abducting and extracting body fluids from humans, ETs show
great skill and an obsessive need for secrecy yet they leave a
memory block any amateur hypnotist can penetrate. If they really
wanted abductees not to know why wouldn't they use rohypnol or
some other 'date rape' drug which actually does blot out short
term memory?

Or are we supposed to assume that their knowledge of chemistry
lags behind our own?

Conversely, if ET is genuinely concerned with secrecy, is it
reasonable to suppose they they'd use their use their advanced
surgical techniques on cattle but not on abductees where they
leave all sorts of scars, scoop marks, burns and blotches?

 >There is a similar question with abduction. ... If they know how to
 >engeneer and modify genetical material why do they bother keeping
 >collecting sperm and eggs samples ? ... Wouldn't it be much simpler to
 >collect a few humans and start a breeding program on their own planet
 >or spaceship ?

A very good question.

Of course, any ETs capable of doing this could also raise their
own cattle.


Joseph Polanik, jpolanik@mindspring.com
Trionic Research Institute, http://www.trionica.com

[ Next Message | Previous Message | This Day's Messages ]
This Month's Index |

UFO UpDates Main Index

UFO UpDates - Toronto - Operated by Errol Bruce-Knapp

Archive programming by Glenn Campbell at Glenn-Campbell.com